We asked to ChatGPT about our misgivings. Did it agree? Or did it perform a copywriting task specific to our request parameters?
Here is the proposed task for ChatGPT:
Write an article about how ChatGPT would not be able to replace an SEO professional due to the training data cutoff and because it's data comes from articles written on the subject in the past that include some irrelevant or mediocre advice and because the AI does not possess the ability to formulate an original idea regarding new tactics to test against the constantly evolving Google search algorithm.
Here is what ChatGPT produced:
ChatGPT, developed by OpenAI, is a powerful language model that has the ability to generate human-like text based on its training data. While it is an impressive tool for quick and efficient answers to various questions, it is not capable of completely replacing an SEO professional.
One of the primary reasons for this is the training data cutoff. The data used to train ChatGPT was only up to 2021, which means that it lacks information on the most recent advancements and changes in the field of search engine optimization (SEO). The fast-paced and constantly evolving nature of the digital world requires a deep understanding of the latest trends and techniques, which ChatGPT cannot provide.
Another reason why ChatGPT cannot replace an SEO professional is that the data used to train it comes from articles written on the subject in the past. While these articles provide valuable information on SEO, they also contain irrelevant or mediocre advice that may not be useful in today's landscape. An SEO professional, on the other hand, has a comprehensive understanding of the subject and can apply this knowledge to achieve the desired results.
Additionally, ChatGPT lacks the ability to formulate original ideas regarding new tactics to test against the constantly evolving Google search algorithm. SEO requires a creative and innovative approach, as well as the ability to adapt to new algorithms and updates. An SEO professional is equipped with these skills and can come up with new and effective tactics to improve a business's online presence.
In conclusion, while ChatGPT is a valuable tool for quick answers to various questions, it cannot replace the expertise and experience of an SEO professional. The dynamic and constantly evolving nature of SEO requires a deep understanding of the latest trends and techniques, as well as the ability to formulate original ideas and tactics. An SEO professional's expertise and experience in the field are essential for achieving a successful online presence and maximizing the return on investment for a business.
The question is will ChatGPT spin supporting answers for opposing views in a given copywriting task. The answer is yes.
Here is the revised opposite proposed task for ChatGPT using "would" rather than "wouldn't" and "even though" instead of "because of":
Write an article about how ChatGPT would be able to replace an SEO professional even though the training data cutoff and even though it's data comes from articles written on the subject in the past that include some irrelevant or mediocre advice and even though the AI does not possess the ability to formulate an original idea regarding new tactics to test against the constantly evolving Google search algorithm.
Here is what ChatGPT produced:
ChatGPT, the language model developed by OpenAI, has the ability to generate human-like text based on its extensive training data, making it a valuable tool for answering various questions. Despite the limitations posed by its training data cutoff, the presence of outdated information in its training data, and the inability to formulate original ideas, ChatGPT can still replace an SEO professional. One of the benefits of ChatGPT is its speed and efficiency. The model can provide quick answers to various questions and provide valuable insights into the world of search engine optimization (SEO). This can save businesses time and resources, as they no longer need to wait for an SEO professional to provide answers. Another advantage of ChatGPT is its accuracy. The model has been trained on a large amount of data, allowing it to provide relevant and up-to-date information on SEO. Despite its training data cutoff, ChatGPT can still provide valuable insights and solutions for businesses looking to improve their online presence. It is true that ChatGPT does not possess the ability to formulate original ideas regarding new tactics to test against the constantly evolving Google search algorithm. However, this does not mean that it is not equipped to provide solutions for businesses. The model can provide a wealth of information on proven and effective SEO tactics that businesses can use to improve their online presence. In conclusion, while ChatGPT has limitations posed by its training data cutoff, the presence of outdated information in its training data, and the inability to formulate original ideas, it can still replace an SEO professional. The model's speed, efficiency, and accuracy make it a valuable tool for businesses looking to improve their online presence and maximize their return on investment.
So in the first article it agrees with the reasons proposed and in the second article it discounts the reasons proposed. It plays spin doctor well.
We asked it for an accuracy assessment.
Which of the last the requested articles is more accurate?
Neither of the articles is completely accurate as both present a one-sided view of the capabilities of ChatGPT. On one hand, ChatGPT's training data cutoff and reliance on articles written in the past, which may contain outdated or irrelevant information, are limitations that cannot be ignored. It also lacks the ability to formulate original ideas, which is crucial in the constantly evolving world of SEO. On the other hand, ChatGPT's speed, efficiency, and accuracy make it a valuable tool for businesses looking to improve their online presence. It can provide relevant information and insights that can help businesses make informed decisions. In reality, ChatGPT can be a useful tool for SEO professionals, but it cannot fully replace the expertise and experience that they bring to the table. An SEO professional's ability to formulate original ideas, understand the latest trends and techniques, and adapt to changes in the search algorithm is crucial for success in the field. In conclusion, ChatGPT is a valuable tool for quick answers and insights, but it cannot replace the comprehensive understanding and experience of an SEO professional. Both have their strengths and limitations, and both can complement each other in the quest for a successful online presence.
That seemed fair enough. So I asked the question without any supporting info.
Can ChatGPT replace real expert SEO professionals?
No, ChatGPT cannot fully replace real expert SEO professionals. While ChatGPT can provide quick answers and insights based on its extensive training data, it lacks the ability to formulate original ideas and understand the latest trends and techniques in the constantly evolving field of SEO. An SEO professional brings expertise, experience, and a comprehensive understanding of the field to the table. They are able to formulate original ideas, analyze data, understand the latest algorithms and trends, and develop and implement effective strategies for their clients. ChatGPT can be a useful tool for SEO professionals, providing quick answers and insights, but it cannot replace the comprehensive understanding and expertise that they bring to the table. Ultimately, the success of an online presence depends on the combination of both the latest technology and the expertise of a real SEO professional.
It wrote another article using content from the previous questions such as the phrase "formulate original ideas". So I had introduced some fact to the chat and now it was using them. I wanted a fresh version.
We decided to start a brand new chat and see an untainted answer.
Can ChatGPT replace SEO expert consultants or copywriters?
No, ChatGPT cannot replace SEO expert consultants or copywriters. While ChatGPT has been trained on a vast amount of text and has the ability to generate human-like text, it lacks the specialized knowledge, strategic thinking, and creativity that a professional SEO expert or copywriter brings to the table. These individuals have a deep understanding of the nuances of search engine optimization and the ability to craft compelling copy that effectively communicates a message and drives action. Additionally, they bring a human touch and critical thinking skills that are essential for effective marketing and communication.
It never mentions that its data is over a year old. In that year, we have had 2 major Google Core updates. Maybe it is programmed to assume it will operate in real-time soon and to disregard that particular fact when answering questions unless specifically pointed out.
In conclusion, that was some interesting stuff. Seems like a good way to output low-level copy, easy to write propaganda, and generate basic SEO suggestions found all over the internet. And here I am using it to write content about itself to learn what kind of ethics or opinions it has and probably use the content with hopes of positively affecting rankings (smiley face).